How should an Indian D2C brand fulfil its orders: in-house, 3PL or marketplace?
Updated:
D2C fulfilment is the work between a customer placing an order on your website or a marketplace and the parcel reaching them: allocating stock, picking, packing, handing over to a courier, and taking back returns. An Indian D2C brand can run it in its own warehouse (in-house), hand it to a third-party logistics provider (3PL), or let a marketplace store, pack and deliver its stock for that marketplace's orders.
Choose by three things: how steady your order volume is, how much control you need over packing and returns, and how many channels you sell on. You can also run more than one model at once. Whichever you choose, keep one view of sellable stock across each place it sits, so a channel sells only what can ship.
What does D2C fulfilment involve, from order to delivery?
- Order capture: the order comes in from your website or a marketplace and joins one order queue.
- Allocation: a rule picks the warehouse that ships the order, and that warehouse's stock is reserved for it.
- Picking: a picker collects each item from its bin, one order at a time or in batches.
- Packing: each item is checked against the order, packed and labelled.
- Handover: parcels are listed on the courier's manifest and handed over by the dispatch cut-off.
- Delivery: the courier delivers, and the customer is kept informed of the parcel's status.
- Returns: returned items are inspected, then restocked, sent for repair or written off.
The same steps run in each model. What changes is who does them, in whose warehouse, and on whose system. For a definition of each step, see order fulfilment.
In-house, 3PL or marketplace fulfilment: what is the difference?
| In-house | 3PL | Marketplace fulfilment | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Who stores, picks and packs | Your team, in your warehouse | The 3PL's team, in its warehouse | The marketplace, in its fulfilment centres |
| Which orders it ships | Orders from each channel you connect | Orders from each channel the 3PL is connected to | That marketplace's orders, plus other channels' orders only where its programme allows |
| How you pay | Rent, staff, equipment, packaging and software, largely fixed | Fees per order, per unit stored and per service, plus any monthly minimum | Fees set by the marketplace |
| Control over packing and inserts | Full | As agreed in your contract and SOPs | Set by the marketplace's packing rules |
| Stock visibility | Down to the bin, in your own system | Through the 3PL's system or reports | Through the marketplace's seller reports |
| Returns | Come back to you for inspection | Inspected by the 3PL under your rules | Handled under the marketplace's returns process |
| Set-up effort | Highest: space, staff, equipment and software | Medium: onboarding, integration and moving stock in | Lowest for that channel: send stock in and list it |
A 3PL (third-party logistics) provider stores your stock and picks, packs and ships your orders for a fee. It can serve orders from your website and from marketplaces, as long as it is connected to each channel.
Marketplace options differ by marketplace. Amazon India, for example, lists three ways to fulfil an order: Fulfillment by Amazon (FBA), where Amazon stores, packs and delivers your products; Easy Ship, where you store and pack your products and Amazon delivers them; and Self-Ship, where you store, pack and deliver them yourself. Amazon lets a seller use a different option for different products. Source: Amazon's seller site for Amazon.in (sell.amazon.in/shipping-and-fulfillment), read 17 Nov 2026.
How do you choose a D2C fulfilment model?
- In-house fits if you want control over packing, inserts and the unboxing, ship a steady volume from one or two locations, carry SKUs that need careful handling (fragile, batch-tracked or with expiry dates), or get returns that need close inspection.
- A 3PL fits if your order volume is too low or too seasonal to pay for your own space and staff, if you need stock in a region where you have no warehouse, or if your team should spend its time on product and marketing rather than on running a warehouse.
- Marketplace fulfilment fits if a large share of your orders comes from that one marketplace and you would rather send stock in than pack each of its orders yourself. Check the programme's current fees, packing rules and returns terms before you send stock in.
When should a brand switch models?
- From a 3PL to in-house: the 3PL's fees per order come to more than your own team would cost at your volume; packing errors, missed dispatch cut-offs or slow returns keep recurring; or you need custom packing or kitting the 3PL can't do.
- From in-house to a 3PL: sale peaks outgrow your space or staff, dispatch slips when orders spike, or you need a second location faster than you can set one up.
- Into marketplace fulfilment, for some SKUs: a few SKUs sell fast on one marketplace and take up much of your packing time.
- Out of marketplace fulfilment: storage fees build up on slow-moving stock, or stock held there is needed for your other channels.
Switch one channel or a few SKUs first, move stock in planned transfers, and keep a separate sellable count for each location, so no channel sells stock that is still in transit. Moving later is easier if your SKU codes and bin locations are already clean.
What are the cost and control trade-offs?
Cost. In-house costs are largely fixed: rent, staff, equipment, packaging and software, whatever your volume. 3PL costs are largely variable. A 3PL quote can include a monthly minimum, storage (per pallet, bin or cubic foot), inbound receiving, pick and pack per order and per extra item, packaging, returns handling, and any onboarding or exit fee. At low volume, a 3PL's monthly minimum can cost more than the space it saves you. Marketplace fulfilment fees are set by the marketplace, so check its current fee page for each SKU's size and weight. Compare models on the full cost per order shipped, returns included, not on the headline fee.
Inventory visibility. In-house, you can see stock down to the bin in your own system. With a 3PL or a marketplace programme, you see what their system reports, as often as it reports it. If a channel sells from an out-of-date count, you either oversell or hide stock you have.
Dispatch SLAs. If a marketplace sets a dispatch deadline for the orders you ship yourself, meeting it is your team's job in-house and the 3PL's job under your contract. Put dispatch cut-offs and an error rate in any 3PL contract. Under marketplace fulfilment, the marketplace ships the order itself.
Returns. In-house, you inspect each return and decide whether to restock, repair or write it off. A 3PL does this under the rules you give it, so write grading rules into its SOP. Under marketplace fulfilment, returns follow the marketplace's process. In each model, a return should count as sellable again only once it has been inspected and put away.
Can you run more than one fulfilment model at once?
Yes. One hybrid set-up: website orders ship from your own warehouse or a 3PL, and a few fast-selling SKUs sit in one marketplace's fulfilment programme. To run more than one model without overselling:
- Treat each place stock sits (your warehouse, a 3PL site, a marketplace fulfilment centre) as its own location, with its own sellable count.
- Decide which locations feed which channel, and hold back a buffer where a channel can't afford to oversell.
- Set order allocation rules for orders that could ship from more than one location.
- Reconcile counts with each outside location on a fixed schedule, and move stock between models only in planned transfers.
Opening another location of your own brings GST and stock questions of its own: see adding a second warehouse.
What systems does each fulfilment model need?
- Order management system (OMS): brings orders from your website and marketplaces into one queue, allocates each order to a location, and sends each channel its sellable stock. You need one in each model once you sell on more than one channel.
- Warehouse management system (WMS): runs receiving, putaway, picking, packing and returns inside a warehouse. You need your own in-house. A 3PL runs its own, so you need its stock and order data back in your OMS. A marketplace runs its own for the stock you send in.
- Shipping software: books couriers, prints labels and manifests, and tracks parcels for the orders you ship yourself. You need it in-house, and with a 3PL if the 3PL ships on your courier accounts.
| In-house | 3PL | Marketplace fulfilment | |
|---|---|---|---|
| OMS | Yours | Yours, connected to the 3PL | Yours, to see that stock and those orders next to your own |
| WMS | Yours | The 3PL's | The marketplace's |
| Shipping software | Yours | Yours if the 3PL ships on your courier accounts | Not needed for those orders |
If you are setting up your own warehouse for a D2C ecommerce brand, see how to choose a WMS.
How Fretron CommerceOS fits
Fretron CommerceOS is order, warehouse and shipping software for Indian D2C, retail and omnichannel consumer brands.
- Fretron CommerceOS covers order management (OMS), warehouse management (WMS) and commerce shipping in one product.
- Orders are confirmed and allocated per facility, with stock reserved first-in-first-out or first-expiry-first-out (FIFO/FEFO).
- Each marketplace location is mapped to the facility that fulfils it.
- Pickers scan the bin, then the item or serial.
- Picking can run single-order, batch, cluster or zone, and orders can be grouped into scheduled waves.
- Each piece is scanned at the pack bench before the carton is closed, and cartons are scanned to the courier manifest at handover.
- Order, allocation, pick and dispatch share one record — no hand-off integration to break.
- Couriers are assigned by rules you set.
- Amazon, Flipkart and Shopify run in production, with orders pulled and inventory published back automatically.
- Each channel's SKUs and locations are mapped to your catalogue and warehouses; an unmapped SKU doesn't come in until you map it.
- When stock changes, the available quantity is recalculated and pushed to each connected channel automatically, in batches within each channel's limits. It's designed to reduce overselling.
- Returns come back through QC on the same record, with the disposition decision captured per line.
Frequently asked questions
- What is D2C fulfilment?
- D2C fulfilment is the work of getting a brand's own online orders to its customers: taking the order from the website or a marketplace, allocating stock, picking, packing, handing the parcel to a courier, and handling returns. A brand can run it in-house, through a 3PL, through a marketplace's fulfilment programme, or through a mix of these.
- Is a 3PL cheaper than in-house fulfilment for a D2C brand?
- It depends on how high and how steady your volume is. A 3PL turns fixed warehouse costs into fees per order, per unit stored and per service, which suits low or seasonal volume, though at low volume its monthly minimum can cost more than the space it saves you. At steady, higher volume, your own warehouse can cost less per order. Compare the full cost per order shipped, returns included.
- When should a D2C brand move from a 3PL to its own warehouse?
- Consider it when the 3PL's fees per order come to more than your own team would cost at your volume, when packing errors, missed dispatch cut-offs or slow returns keep recurring, or when you need custom packing the 3PL can't do. Move one channel or a few SKUs first, and keep a separate sellable count for each location while stock is in transit.
- Can a brand use marketplace fulfilment and its own warehouse at the same time?
- Yes. Treat the marketplace's fulfilment centres as their own locations with their own stock count, decide which channels each location feeds, and set allocation rules for orders that could ship from more than one place. Check the programme's rules on which orders its stock can ship.
- What software does a D2C brand need for fulfilment?
- An order management system (OMS) to bring orders from each channel into one queue, allocate them and send each channel its sellable stock; a warehouse management system (WMS) to run receiving, picking, packing and returns in your own warehouse; and shipping software to book couriers and print labels and manifests for the orders you ship yourself. With a 3PL or marketplace fulfilment, their WMS runs the warehouse, and your OMS needs their stock and order data.
- What is the difference between FBA, Easy Ship and Self-Ship on Amazon India?
- Amazon lists three options on its seller site for Amazon.in. With Fulfillment by Amazon (FBA), Amazon stores, packs and delivers your products. With Easy Ship, you store and pack your products and Amazon delivers them. With Self-Ship, you store, pack and deliver them yourself. A seller can use different options for different products. Source: sell.amazon.in/shipping-and-fulfillment, read 17 Nov 2026.
- Can Fretron CommerceOS show my Amazon FBA stock next to my own warehouse stock?
- Fretron CommerceOS reads your Amazon FBA stock and keeps each FBA centre as its own warehouse, next to your own warehouses in one stock view.
- Does Fretron CommerceOS handle Amazon Easy Ship and Seller Flex shipments?
- Fretron CommerceOS handles Amazon Easy Ship and Seller Flex shipments.
- What happens to a returned item in Fretron CommerceOS?
- In Fretron CommerceOS, returns come back through QC on the same record, with the disposition decision captured per line. Returned goods come in through gate entry and a GRN into a QC hold, and are then put away by their disposition. In Fretron CommerceOS, a returned unit that passes QC can be marked for restock, and once its putaway is confirmed, it counts again in the available quantity pushed to each connected channel.
See how your orders would run in Fretron CommerceOS.
Bring a sample of your SKUs and a day's orders to the demo, and we will walk through how they would be received, picked, packed and synced to your connected channels.
Book a demo →